The Evolution of One Piece: From a Simple Prototype to an Epic Adventure
Over the course of almost three decades, Eiichiro Oda's One Piece manga has undergone some incredible changes from Chapter 1 to now. After all that time, big changes are the least manga readers can expect, but the changes could have been even more drastic. Even if the Romance Dawn arc feels like a whole different manga compared to the post-time skip chapters, the very first iteration of One Piece was even more exotic.
Even a mega-successful author like Mr. Oda may need more than one shot to get his manga figured out and launch the shonen adventure for real. In 1996, he published a one-shot chapter for One Piece, one that didn't end up getting serialized. It was for the best that the original version didn't set sail beyond Chapter 1, though it's still fun to compare the first attempt at One Piece to the current version. For that matter, it's a good reference for how the actual manga needed to change over time as well.
What Was the Original One Piece Like?
Eiichiro Oda's First Chapter Didn't Necessarily Set Up an Epic Story
Even longtime One Piece manga readers in the West might not have laid eyes on author Eiichiro Oda's first pass at Monkey D. Luffy's pirate adventure, though the print version of Shonen Jump in North America did reveal this one-shot chapter in the early 2010s. Anyone who found that chapter must have been amused by how familiar but also different this version of One Piece felt. It definitely felt like a modest prototype of the epic pirate manga to follow, with a single double-length chapter depicting Luffy as a roving rogue who loves his straw hat above all else.
Familiar elements such as that hat, Luffy's rubbery powers via the Gum-Gum Fruit, and the eternal struggle against evil pirate captains are all present in 1996's One Piece manga chapter, though many other elements were missing, too. Higuma and his mountain bandits were absent, replaced by a simple villain named Crescent Moon Gary, a token pirate captain who antagonizes Luffy in the chapter. Gary doesn't have anything interesting to say or do aside from generic pirate antics, and no one except Luffy had any supernatural powers. There was no mention of other Devil Fruits, suggesting that the Gum-Gum Fruit was the only one, and there was certainly no mention of the Haki combat system, either. Thus, 1996's One Piece chapter was far more grounded than what fans are used to today.
Even the actual manga's own Romance Dawn arc has more supernatural aspects than that, such as Buggy the Clown's Chop-Chop Fruit to prove that many kinds of Devil Fruit exist. Most of all, the excitement of seeing Luffy recruiting new crewmates is mostly absent, with him awakening at the chapter's end with a small crew already assembled.
In short, while the 1996 chapter did help establish many essential ingredients to launch One Piece's story, it was also a rather stripped-down take on the idea, perhaps too much so. Every manga has to start off simple to welcome new readers, including One Piece, but foreshadowing is still welcome. The actual Romance Dawn arc in the main One Piece manga did a better job with the now-famous worldbuilding while also having far more characters of note.
The Shonen Big Three All Needed Prototype Chapters to Launch
No One Gets It Right the First Time
Eiichiro Oda isn't alone in the fact that he needed more than one version of One Piece to start serializing Luffy's high-seas adventures. It's not uncommon for even the most successful manga artists to need two or more attempts at their stories to begin an epic story, and Mr. Oda is in good company. He is joined by Masashi Kishimoto of Naruto fame and Tite Kubo of Bleach fame, each of whom had their own prototypes before their actual manga series took off in the pages of Weekly Shonen Jump. Thus, all three members of the famed shonen "big three" needed to walk before they could run, with all three authors refining and enhancing their creative visions before manga history could be made.
The 1996 One Piece prototype chapter gave way to a more focused chapter with a more meaningful villain and a preview of Color of the Supreme King Haki, a clear improvement over what Mr. Oda initially drew. Similarly, the first pass at Naruto had some amusing elements, but didn't feel like the beginning of something truly epic the way the first proper Naruto chapter does. The initial chapter of Naruto was a whole different animal from what shonen fans actually got, literally so in some ways. The first attempt at Naruto Uzumaki made him a mischievous fox creature who could resemble humans, and he was sent to befriend humans in a world with modern technology.
Tite Kubo's first attempt at Bleach wasn't the right stuff to launch an epic shonen manga, and after getting rejected, Mr. Kubo was on the verge of giving up. That was when Akira Toriyama himself sent Mr. Kubo a letter of encouragement, inspiring Bleach's author to keep at it until he ended up serializing. As for what Tite Kubo originally drew, the first Bleach chapter was roughly similar to what fans have read in the real version, but many major and minor differences exist, too. Aside from different aesthetics, the prototype Bleach chapter depicted Orihime Inoue's death, with her deceased father arriving to escort her to the waiting Soul Society. The chapter also revealed Ichigo's Soul Reaper heritage, something that wasn't revealed as a shocking surprise until much later in the real manga.
One Piece's Actual Manga Had to Change Over Time, Too
The Journey Must Give Way to the Destination Eventually
Fans can see all kinds of differences between the 1996 One Piece one-shot and the manga's current contents, but that's not the only comparison to be made with early One Piece material. Even the canon Romance Dawn manga arc is worlds apart from what readers are now seeing in the Final Saga, but that's nothing to be concerned about. Even the most epic and breathtaking manga like One Piece needs to start slow before it builds up everything, and that gives the manga a proper sense of growth over the years.
The early chapters aren't underwhelming or disappointing to revisit — they're a marker for how far One Piece has come, and that makes the early chapters more nostalgic and special, not less. As for the differing narrative styles, some readers may miss how the early chapters focused on simple and fun pirate adventures where anything could happen and the horizon beckoned, while the current saga is heavy and complicated with all its lore.
It's true the spirit of adventure has been partially edged out in favor of slow, epic worldbuilding and expansive lore, but that was bound to happen eventually. Fans got to read nearly 30 years of carefree adventure before reaching this point, more than enough time to savor the original spirit of One Piece before the manga entered its current state. The journey from 1997 to now was the adventure of a lifetime, and for a time, it felt like it would never end.
Besides, the One Piece manga never completely gave up its spirit of adventure, not even in the Elbaph story arc with all its lore dumps and mysteries. The Straw Hats are still sailing from one exotic island to another, a scaled-up version of what fans saw in both versions of Romance Dawn. These two sides of One Piece feel incredibly distant but still connected in fundamental ways, which counts for a lot. And there's still one more romantic adventure for the Straw Hats to undertake before it's all over: reach Laugh Tale, a place hardly anyone else has ever visited, and claim the ultimate treasure. That's a goal even the 1996 Romance Dawn Luffy can appreciate.
Post a Comment